Oracle News Desk
Oracle-Sun: Gartner Suspects EC of Ulterior Motives
Donald Feinberg says either the EC knows zip about open source or there’s “another agenda”
By: Maureen O'Gara
Sep. 11, 2009 11:45 AM
Gartner database analyst Donald Feinberg [pictured below giving a recent webinar that's still available for online viewing] and his colleague George Weiss told Cnet that the only reason the European Commission is holding up the Oracle-Sun deal on the pretext of investigating Oracle’s intentions on MySQL is “political” and “protectionist” – as though the rest of us didn’t know that already.
Feinberg says either the EC knows zip about open source – since the Maria DB MySQL fork would take over for MySQL if Oracle neglected it – or there’s “another agenda” – and introduces the specter of Oracle abandoning the deal, leaving Sun in the devastating lurch.
And “Who would benefit?” he’s asked. Well, “All the hardware companies out there, including the European hardware companies.”
He suspects that the EC is acting at the bidding of Oracle rivals like IBM and HP and to protect European vendors such as SAP, Bull, Software AG, even Fujitsu with its large European presence.
And he’s pretty sure the EC really wants to “stop this deal.”
Feinberg suggests that because Sun had negative 40% growth last quarter – and with every Sun competitor trying to raid its installed base – “at some point Oracle has to ask the question, do they still want to buy the company?”
He also suspects that the EC will drag the investigation out as long as possible unless it’s forced to “yield to market pressure.”
“You have to ask yourself,” he says, “if Larry Ellison and Charles Phillips just get so fed up with this whole thing that they throw their arms up in the air and say it’s not worth it. I would suspect the frustrations have to be running pretty high inside Oracle right now.”
He doesn’t think Oracle will stand for any demand to divest MySQL or much of any other concessions, leaving Sun to dangle in the wind and the longer the deal is up in the air the more Sun users will bolt.
Reader Feedback: Page 1 of 1
SOA World Latest Stories
Subscribe to the World's Most Powerful Newsletters
Subscribe to Our Rss Feeds & Get Your SYS-CON News Live!
SYS-CON Featured Whitepapers
Most Read This Week