Comments
suedunnell wrote: Hi Again - I should add my name to comment #1 above and ask that if anyone has questions, they can either post them here or ask me directly: Sue Dunnell PowerBuilder Product Manager 978 287 1752 sue.dunnell@sybase.com
Cloud Computing
Conference & Expo
November 2-4, 2009 NYC
Register Today and SAVE !..


2008 West
DIAMOND SPONSOR:
Data Direct
SOA, WOA and Cloud Computing: The New Frontier for Data Services
PLATINUM SPONSORS:
Red Hat
The Opening of Virtualization
GOLD SPONSORS:
Appsense
User Environment Management – The Third Layer of the Desktop
Cordys
Cloud Computing for Business Agility
EMC
CMIS: A Multi-Vendor Proposal for a Service-Based Content Management Interoperability Standard
Freedom OSS
Practical SOA” Max Yankelevich
Intel
Architecting an Enterprise Service Router (ESR) – A Cost-Effective Way to Scale SOA Across the Enterprise
Sensedia
Return on Assests: Bringing Visibility to your SOA Strategy
Symantec
Managing Hybrid Endpoint Environments
VMWare
Game-Changing Technology for Enterprise Clouds and Applications
Click For 2008 West
Event Webcasts

2008 West
PLATINUM SPONSORS:
Appcelerator
Get ‘Rich’ Quick: Rapid Prototyping for RIA with ZERO Server Code
Keynote Systems
Designing for and Managing Performance in the New Frontier of Rich Internet Applications
GOLD SPONSORS:
ICEsoft
How Can AJAX Improve Homeland Security?
Isomorphic
Beyond Widgets: What a RIA Platform Should Offer
Oracle
REAs: Rich Enterprise Applications
Click For 2008 Event Webcasts
I just read SYS-CON's response to the recent attacks in Fuat Kircaali's Social Media Terrorists blog entry. I realized the email quoted at the end of Kircaali's blog was also copied to Ted Weissman of Lois Paul & Partners, a public relations firm with clients in technology. If this email was sen...
SYS-CON.TV
The Well-Spoken SOA - How Well Is Your SOA Running?
Understanding the elements of an SOA in the context of management, security, governance, and the power of words

The American comedian and actor Steven Wright once said, "It doesn't make a difference what temperature a room is, it's always room temperature." Words are wonderful that way. They can give you a little blast of pleasure when used cleverly, but like everything else they are subject to fashion. For example, I was speaking at a technical conference recently when I overheard a person whom I know, who is well-respected in this field, say something along these lines: "You have to know how well your SOA is running. Knowing the overall health and responsiveness of your SOA is very important. You've got to get a handle on your governance." The goal was laudable, but the wording was off target.

I've heard the word governance fall from people's lips with increasing frequency recently, which is a good thing. Lately though, it seems to me that there has been an unfortunate blurring of the usage and definition of the word governance with another important word that also ought to be on the tip of the tongues of most people involved with SOA today, and that word is management. Monitoring and controlling the overall health and responsiveness of your SOA is largely a function of management, not governance.

The person whom I mentioned above probably knows this, at least in his better moments, but fashion is a powerful force. Trust me on this. You may consider yourself an up-to-date person both technically and in your style of language and dress, but I assure you, fashions change. Many years from now, photos of you wearing cloths that were once considered the height of fashion may cause your very own children to turn on you. There is no defense against the younger generation when they sense vulnerability any more than you can convince a shark in the midst of a feeding frenzy to try tofu. Speaking from a theoretical perspective, naturally, my advice is to be prepared for the likes of "Gee, Dad, how could you have possibly gone out in public dressed that way?"

A good response is to flash your progeny a peace sign and beat a hasty retreat.

Similarly, in order to spare our dear readers the potential embarrassment of explaining to future generations of telepathic IT people what an SOA was and why we even cared about it, it seems prudent to review and solidify our own architectural understanding. Let us consider the functional elements of an SOA starting with those elements responsible for the actual creation and execution of services. Later, we will focus on other essential elements such as management, governance, and security, and we'll examine their role in the SOA and their relationship with the rest of the IT infrastructure upon which the SOA depends, as well.

Creation and Execution of Services
Many well-known types of enterprise software such as application servers, integration servers, and large business systems have evolved to provide the essential elements needed to create and run services in an SOA. Most often these are Web services based on protocols such as SOAP, but can include other types of services based on technologies such as CORBA or Java RMI as well. These newly evolved entities are often called service platforms. Service platforms minimally provide a service runtime environment for the execution of services, but are often bundled with tools that provide many other capabilities. Most commonly, they include development tools that provide the ability to develop and deploy services to that same runtime environment. Therefore, it is no surprise that most application servers and their associated development environments have been transformed and remarketed as service platforms.

SOA is also about breaking down the barriers between previously isolated legacy application silos and reusing these capabilities in new, more flexible ways. Therefore, both integration servers and messaging middleware vendors, which often have more specialized mechanisms in order to work with legacy systems, have joined the service platform game as well. In fact, a wide range of diverse platforms and technologies are transforming themselves into services platforms. For example, many application vendors such as SAP are also offering service platforms that provide the added benefit of leveraging the business application itself.

Many of these service platforms feature embellished tools that are helpful in designing and creating a modern SOA, including support for many Web services standards. These platforms are usually capable of composing simple Web services into more complex composite ones, and frequently provide orchestration engines so you can more easily create high-level business processes out of these services. They are designed to aid reusability by making it easy find new services via discovery mechanisms (typically UDDI registries), another element of SOA, which they often include as part of a complete service platform package.

Despite their architectural, technical, and functional diversity, one thing that many service platforms have in common these days is that they increasingly follow the current fashion of calling themselves an Enterprise Service Bus or ESB (a previously fashionable word was "fabric," but that has now fallen into disfavor). In my opinion, this was a smart move from the marketing perspective because it creates the impression of an indivisible and essential component. After all, what computer can operate without its bus?

However, unlike a computer bus, elements of an SOA related to the service-oriented applications themselves such as development, runtime, orchestration, transformation, guaranteed message delivery, or registry can also be provided by more specialized stand-alone products, depending on the needs of the organization. As these capabilities become increasingly mature and commoditized (a challenge that J2EE application servers started to face a few years ago), many organizations have already found that they have multiple ESBs and point-products with overlapping capabilities.

Service Platform Limitations
For many organizations, the success of the SOA may ultimately be more dependent upon other SOA elements, such as operations management and security management. As different types of service platforms proliferate, the management and security challenges become more difficult. Why can't service platforms easily provide these capabilities in an SOA? They often promote themselves as "all you ever need to build an SOA." In fact many service platforms do provide limited management and security capabilities. However many service platforms are quite rightly focused on maximizing the benefits of their own technology stack, rather than leveraging and increasing the value and utility of all service platforms that participate in an SOA. Indeed, the service platform vendor may have limited experience or incentive to leverage the management and security capabilities of any platform but its own.

About Paul Lipton
Paul Lipton is an Advisor and Senior Architect in CA, Inc. where he leads the CA Industry Standards and Open Source Program in the Office of the CTO. Paul has been an architect and developer of enterprise systems for over 20 years. He serves on the Board of Directors of the DMTF and the Eclipse Foundation, and has participated in many other industry organizations such as OASIS and the W3C. Paul is a founding member of the CA Council for Technical Excellence where he chairs the Emerging Technology Committee and also leads a project focused on leveraging Web 2.0 to improve research collaboration. He is also a Microsoft Most Valuable Professional and a Sun Java Champion. Paul is a highly sought-after author and speaker, and has shared his knowledge with appreciative audiences around the world covering topics such as industry standards, SOA, open source, technical innovation, enterprise architecture, social computing, virtualization, Web services, management/security, governance, autonomic computing, Web 2.0, and many other emerging technologies.

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

Register | Sign-in

Reader Feedback: Page 1 of 1

No, UDDI is not fated for the dustbin of history, but neither is it the only way to share or distribute policy information. The notion that UDDI must the the center of the universe and holder of all policy is equally absurd. It simply won't happen for practical and historical reasons. Policy will be distributed all over the place; in legacy, identity management, and operations management policy repositories, to name a few. Each of these repositories is optimized to support certain types of policy best at runtime (where it counts). We had best learn to live with that and plan for it.

The Well-Spoken SOA Web Services - How Well Is Your SOA Running? The American comedian and actor Steven Wright once said, 'It doesn't make a difference what temperature a room is, it's always room temperature.' Words are wonderful that way. They can give you a little blast of pleasure when used cleverly, but like everything else they are subject to fashion. For example, I was speaking at a technical conference recently when I overheard a person whom I know, who is well-respected in this field, say something along these lines: 'You have to know how well your SOA is running. Knowing the overall health and responsiveness of your SOA is very important. You've got to get a handle on your governance.' The goal was laudable, but the wording was off target.


Your Feedback
Paul Lipton wrote: No, UDDI is not fated for the dustbin of history, but neither is it the only way to share or distribute policy information. The notion that UDDI must the the center of the universe and holder of all policy is equally absurd. It simply won't happen for practical and historical reasons. Policy will be distributed all over the place; in legacy, identity management, and operations management policy repositories, to name a few. Each of these repositories is optimized to support certain types of policy best at runtime (where it counts). We had best learn to live with that and plan for it.
SOA Web Services Journal wrote: The Well-Spoken SOA Web Services - How Well Is Your SOA Running? The American comedian and actor Steven Wright once said, 'It doesn't make a difference what temperature a room is, it's always room temperature.' Words are wonderful that way. They can give you a little blast of pleasure when used cleverly, but like everything else they are subject to fashion. For example, I was speaking at a technical conference recently when I overheard a person whom I know, who is well-respected in this field, say something along these lines: 'You have to know how well your SOA is running. Knowing the overall health and responsiveness of your SOA is very important. You've got to get a handle on your governance.' The goal was laudable, but the wording was off target.
SOA World Latest Stories
Want to know what gets my blood pressure up? It’s when there’s both a huge shift in thinking around how we should do computing, namely cloud computing, and at the same time, there’s a bunch of information out there that causes confusion. As cloud computing hype spikes to a frenzy, so d...
"What's fueling the interest in RIA?" asked Regev Yativ, President & CEO of Magic Software Enterprises in the Americas, at the beginning of his session at AJAX World RIA Conference & Expo in NYC last month. The answer is the growth of broadband, Yativ said, which has made the Internet ...
System architects and engineering teams are designing increasingly complex embedded systems in order to satisfy their customers’ stringent functionality and performance requirements. In addition, within tactical systems, it’s not uncommon to require deterministic real-time behavior whi...
With the spoils of the BEA acquisition now fully baked into the mix -- and with anticipation for what the pending Sun Microsystems buy brings -- Oracle is well on its way to obviating the middleware moniker. Perhaps we should call it "anyware."
Oracle has announced the general availability of Oracle Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) Suite 11g, which helps customers and partners to lower costs, improve efficiencies and increase visibility into their businesses and operations. This next-generation business application infrast...
As part of today's Oracle(R) Fusion Middleware 11g launch, Oracle announced that Oracle Fusion Middleware remains the Company's fastest growing business. Oracle's commitment to delivering innovative products strengthened Oracle Fusion Middleware's position as an industry leader in vend...
Subscribe to the World's Most Powerful Newsletters
Subscribe to Our Rss Feeds & Get Your SYS-CON News Live!
Click to Add our RSS Feeds to the Service of Your Choice:
Google Reader or Homepage Add to My Yahoo! Subscribe with Bloglines Subscribe in NewsGator Online
myFeedster Add to My AOL Subscribe in Rojo Add 'Hugg' to Newsburst from CNET News.com Kinja Digest View Additional SYS-CON Feeds
Publish Your Article! Please send it to editorial(at)sys-con.com!

Advertise on this site! Contact advertising(at)sys-con.com! 201 802-3021


SYS-CON Featured Whitepapers


ADS BY GOOGLE