Java Industry News
ORACLE BEA: Chuang Rejects Oracle's Hostile Bid
Can BEA run and hide?
Nov. 17, 2007 12:15 PM
(October 19, 2007) - It's unclear where BEA is going to run and hide to avoid a
shotgun wedding, but its board late Friday rejected Oracle's $6.66 billion
marriage proposal.
I
n a letter to Oracle that the board made public it expressed
irritation that Oracle had made its wooing known and rated Oracle's $17-a-share
offer as undervalued, a position that the board found reinforced by the fact
that the stock was bid up over Oracle's offer price Friday once the market
realized that Oracle was making a hostile run at BEA.
Evidently BEA failed to turn up at a rendezvous. Oracle says
BEA had agreed to meet at 10 o'clock Pacific time Friday morning to work out a
definitive agreement by Monday, but cancelled it late Thursday night and
"refused to reschedule."
BEA's board told Oracle it was getting ahead of itself and
that the BEA board had not agreed to meet with Oracle Friday morning "to
commence a process and we did not agree to your proposal that the process
result in definite agreement by Monday," adding coyly that "We did
not say there is 'no process' with Oracle that would result in friendly
deal." However, it suggested that it would be worth more to others.
To which Oracle, which is promising to remain
"friendly" if it gets what it wants quickly, asked, "Whether
there was any process that BEA would prefer to follow to move towards a
friendly transaction and was told that BEA had no such process in mind."
According to the Wall Street Journal, BEA passed on the
meeting because Oracle asked it to bring what BEA figured was way too much
information about its business along with it – presumably the kind that's
reflected in the price bid.
All of which explains why Oracle went public with its offer
Friday morning and why Oracle claims to be committed to its price, which it now
describes as a 40% premium over BEA's share price in mid-August before Carl
Icahn waded in.
If BEA hopes for a white knight it can apparently scratch
out SAP's name. SAP, which just announced a deal to acquire Business Objects
for $6.8 billion, told the Financial Times it's not interested in BEA because
of the overlap, though SAP CEO Henning Kagermann also told the paper SAP could
make other big acquisitions. What he could possibly have in mind is unclear.
Icahn, who is trying to drive the sales price up as far as
it can go, has offered HP and IBM as possible alternatives. IBM of course would
seem to have an antitrust issue and HP, like SAP, has said it's not interested,
but that doesn't mean it's true.
About Oracle News DeskOracle News Desk trawls the world's news information sources and brings you timely updates on Oracle and its ever-expanding enterprise software portfolio, including its entire range of tools for managing business data, supporting business operations, and facilitating collaboration and application development.